"Ridiculous numbers!" Who would you rather have - Erling Haaland or Kylian Mbappé


Gary Lineker, Rio Ferdinand, Joe Cole and Owen Hargreaves discuss two incredibly special players young stars - Erling Haaland and Kylian Mbappé.
Hit 'Subscribe' above to ensure you never miss a video from the BT Sport NOprojects channel.
Click here to purchase a BT Sport Monthly Pass - bit.ly/BTSportMonthlyPass
Visit and subscribe to our 'BT Sport Boxing' NOprojects channel ➡️ noprojects.info
Twitter: btsport
Facebook: btsport
Instagram: btsport
Website: sport.bt.com


  • Marvin Nash
    Marvin Nash2 timer siden

    I'd take Haaland over Mbappé any day. Makes his whole team stronger with his mentality. And on his position there is no one else around under 30. But there are a lot of great wingers.

  • Jay B
    Jay BDag siden

    Haaland... Mbappe has some tantrum moments to grow out of still.

  • Iso
    IsoDag siden

    For me rn it is Mbappe, because that game against Barca just showed his talent and the attitude, that made Ronaldo and Messi so impressive - he made the difference. But I feel like Haaland struggles to make the difference, as he needs players that assist him all the time

  • niduoe stre
    niduoe stre3 dager siden

    Ronaldo and Messi’ skills were on a whole new lvl

  • Zaheda Siddiqui
    Zaheda Siddiqui3 dager siden

    For me its always haaland😊 But for now CR7!!! SIUUUUUU

  • AVID Sion
    AVID Sion3 dager siden

    Both of them play in farmers leagues, so I'll wait until they have to play decent teams on a regular basis to decide. If I had to fathom a guess who will do better in the event of a transfer to Spain/England though, my money's on Haaland because he seems just a bit more clinical and he has the physical advantage being 6'4 as a striker.

  • niduoe stre

    niduoe stre

    3 dager siden

    Considering Haaland plays as a 9, Mbappe doesn't.

  • Emil Cioran
    Emil Cioran3 dager siden

    Mbappe slightly less goals? 30% is not slightly less

  • Rafael Cruz
    Rafael Cruz3 dager siden

    It’s nice to see two lions out of the gate, but Messi and Cristiano have done it for more than a decade. Neymar never even makes it into the conversation. Too early to compare the youngsters to the icons

  • R .D
    R .D3 dager siden

    I think Mbappe will achieve more in his career but Haaland will be statistically better

  • James
    James4 dager siden

    Lewandowski just pushed aside for the last 5 seasons.

  • Rahul Mohanraj
    Rahul Mohanraj4 dager siden

    I would rather have Rashford

  • Anthony MAHIEU
    Anthony MAHIEU4 dager siden

    M'bappe is overrated. Haaland is better.

    YOUR COUSIN5 dager siden

    There is Lewandowski! Chill out! He has the crown 👑

  • Harry Cech
    Harry Cech5 dager siden

    I had no idea who Haaland was, but since I've found out who he is, man, like his play, I'm officially on team Haaland

  • Ayanda Nyanga jr
    Ayanda Nyanga jr6 dager siden

    And a rivalry was born

  • Son
    Son6 dager siden

    Mbappe plays in farmers league so don't count his goals until he moves to another league.

  • Brown Iverson
    Brown Iverson6 dager siden

    Both no doubt. Rather have them than no names on manager mode

  • Señoritas Top's
    Señoritas Top's6 dager siden

    Halan. Mejor que mbappe

  • Red or Dead
    Red or Dead6 dager siden

    Haaland all day!!🔴⚪⚫

  • Ptao Tom
    Ptao Tom6 dager siden

    The “farmers” keeps creating quality!

  • Leonidas
    Leonidas6 dager siden

    Mbappe because he is a very fast black man.

  • RestonsPolis
    RestonsPolis6 dager siden

    Considering Haaland plays as a 9, Mbappe doesn't.

  • Akha Nonxuba
    Akha Nonxuba7 dager siden

    Mbappe first of all is a FIFA World Cup winner🏆. Haaland will definitely win the Ballon d'Or in the future. Maybe more than once. In terms of ability, they're planets ahead. Think Foden ,Fati, Felix and Vinicius Jr might come good and suprise a few people. How can I forget about Pedro Neto!

  • Ptao Tom

    Ptao Tom

    6 dager siden

    Haaland will be the best player in the world in some years

  • Nick Wyllie
    Nick Wyllie7 dager siden

    2003-2020 Ronaldo vs Messi 2021 Haaland vs Mbappe 2025+ Lingard

  • Hatuna Matata
    Hatuna Matata7 dager siden

    Thats not even a question, Haaland is just better and more effective than Mbappe

  • Leonard Orji Offor
    Leonard Orji Offor7 dager siden

    Its purely rubbish in comparing Mbampe with Haaland in these stage of their games, Haaland is yet to justify the hyper about him

  • Andrew Lomas
    Andrew Lomas7 dager siden

    French league isn't the hardest really is it.

  • TheBxtux
    TheBxtux7 dager siden

    Haaland two years younger, and doing it with a worse team in a harder league..

  • Anthony Joyce
    Anthony Joyce7 dager siden

    Haaland is an out and out scorer but mbappe plays out wide aswell as upfront. Both amazing players. Kind of like the shearer and Thierry debate. One was more skillfull and one scored more. Personally would rather have haaland

  • pallyali786
    pallyali7867 dager siden

    Mbappe is already a world cup winner

  • Neem Noa
    Neem Noa7 dager siden

    Comparing them to Henry and Zlatan is much more apt I think. Both of them legendary strikers but the true GOAT club is limited to Pelé, Maradona, Messi and Ronaldo (and maybe Puskás).

  • jam bibat
    jam bibat7 dager siden

    Haaland vs Mbappe will be the next Ronaldo vs Messi debate

  • Paresh Seejaram
    Paresh Seejaram7 dager siden


    HAMZA7 dager siden

    Neymar: 😭 Im here guys....

  • By Lipsy
    By Lipsy8 dager siden

    They are like Messi Ronaldo, One is a machine, and the other the beauty

  • Smith Smith
    Smith Smith8 dager siden

    Wayne can go f**k himself

  • J Mc
    J Mc8 dager siden

    Haaland, not close.

  • Solidus Snake
    Solidus Snake8 dager siden

    Haaland will be the best player in the world in some years

  • Heisenberg
    Heisenberg8 dager siden

    The mindset of Haaland ist much stronger, he's hungry for every goal so he will be the better player

  • huttio srreu
    huttio srreu8 dager siden

    Haalands playstyle reminds me of a viking storming to the goal like "VALHALLAAAA"

  • Mark Margiotta
    Mark Margiotta8 dager siden

    this is tru but the numbers are also in Ligue 1 and Bundesliga not counting champions league I think the premier league and Spanish league are just a little above these two leagues

  • mcdelive
    mcdelive8 dager siden

    Rashford left the building ;)

  • General Kunta
    General Kunta8 dager siden

    Ligue 1 and Bundesliga stats? Really? 😂

  • huttio srreu

    huttio srreu

    8 dager siden


  • Ron Wayne
    Ron Wayne8 dager siden

    The genius of messi and ronaldo is their consistency in those 12 years We are takin it for granted !!!

  • Manu
    Manu8 dager siden

    This conversation will end in couple of years... Mark my words.. mbappe will be a flop when he enter into a much better league... Halland on other hand will rise to the occasion..

  • yaliso gioouy
    yaliso gioouy8 dager siden

    Both have common Idol : CR7 🔥

  • S S
    S S8 dager siden

    Finally we found players who gonna replace Ronaldo and Messi. Unfortunately not Hazard and Neymar. 😂

  • J90JAM
    J90JAM8 dager siden

    It's crazy that not even long after the Ronaldo & Messi era that we might have two players that could surpass them both 😳

  • I hate youtube I love YouTube
    I hate youtube I love YouTube8 dager siden

    Harland On any day..he is the best

  • yaliso gioouy

    yaliso gioouy

    8 dager siden

    Here we go again....

  • Shaun L
    Shaun L8 dager siden

    Haaland all day long Mbappe is mediocre at best

  • N9ne 9999

    N9ne 9999

    8 dager siden

    @Mustafa المحارب النوبي He plays in a farmer league.

  • Mustafa المحارب النوبي

    Mustafa المحارب النوبي

    8 dager siden

    Mbappe is a better player

  • TetsuoShimaNo41
    TetsuoShimaNo418 dager siden

    Following this discussion, Hargreaves got injured sipping his water, out for 4 months.

  • Christoph Daum auf Entzug
    Christoph Daum auf Entzug8 dager siden

    Haalands playstyle reminds me of a viking storming to the goal like "VALHALLAAAA"

  • Two Views
    Two Views8 dager siden

    They can't do it for 10years

  • chamber maid
    chamber maid8 dager siden

    1:21 And in unison, these four figureheads of the football occult chanted the words "the changing of the guard;" casting their sorcery, and thus elevating Haaland and Mbappe into the realms of the divine.

  • Dennis Piotrowski
    Dennis Piotrowski8 dager siden


  • Dennis Piotrowski

    Dennis Piotrowski

    8 dager siden

    @Mustafa المحارب النوبي idc about winning world cup, I don't think Norway have any chances to win a competition. But nvm, let's see what the future brings. I never said mbappe is bad or something, but I prefer haaland and I really love him as a football player. Not taking instapics after losing a match.

  • Mustafa المحارب النوبي

    Mustafa المحارب النوبي

    8 dager siden

    @Dennis Piotrowski Winning mentality.. but what has haaland won?? Mbappe has won UEFA u19 cup, in 2016 Mbappé ended the 2016-17 season with 26 goals from 44 matches in all competitions as Monaco won the Ligue 1 title and they made it to the semi in CL... We all saw him destroyed city.. won a world cup and was Frances top scorer.. won 3 league titles with psg... And he's 21.. what more do u want from the lad🤣🤣..

  • Dennis Piotrowski

    Dennis Piotrowski

    8 dager siden

    @Mustafa المحارب النوبي idc what he can theoretical, I care about impact. I would take haaland every time and in every situation about mbappe. I don't like his character at all, Haaland has a winner mentality. Same for neymar, idc about players like him, they are never that impactful as a player with a winning mentality.

  • Mustafa المحارب النوبي

    Mustafa المحارب النوبي

    8 dager siden

    Mbappe better dribbling, passing, intelligence, agality, better link up play... Mbappe has everything over Haaland

  • Bolia Fops
    Bolia Fops8 dager siden

    Ronaldo and Messi’ skills were on a whole new lvl

  • Valabala Valabala
    Valabala Valabala9 dager siden

    Haaland 100%

  • Mustafa المحارب النوبي

    Mustafa المحارب النوبي

    8 dager siden

    @Valabala Valabala Mbappe has performed on the biggest stage in the world cup.. that alone speaks about mentality

  • Mustafa المحارب النوبي

    Mustafa المحارب النوبي

    8 dager siden

    @Valabala Valabala Better goals..lolol.. a goal is a goal.. Mbappe is a better player.. haaland is natural scorer a big pyshical player.. he's dependent on service... Mbappe because of better dribbling, passing,pace and link up play offers more than haaland...

  • Valabala Valabala

    Valabala Valabala

    8 dager siden

    @Mustafa المحارب النوبي haaland scores better and stronger body and mentallity also 2 years younger

  • Mustafa المحارب النوبي

    Mustafa المحارب النوبي

    8 dager siden

    Mbappe better footballer

  • bahriboy
    bahriboy9 dager siden

    Joe Cole said we hadn't seen this before..he was wrong. Ronaldo at 20 scored 47 in 49 for Barca.. More goals in a stronger league than either of these 2. Such a shame re his injures.

  • john donkor
    john donkor9 dager siden

    If mbappe develops the scoring habit of Christiano Ronaldo man forget no one can compete with him already his impact to the game winning World Cup at his 18 20 yrs old is the evidence of him being the greatest.

  • Bolia Fops

    Bolia Fops

    8 dager siden

    On the pitch they may be comparable but on the mic there is only one worth listening to.

  • Savez Amir Butt
    Savez Amir Butt9 dager siden

    I am so proud to say that a Norwegian player is the future.

  • CheeseSauce
    CheeseSauce9 dager siden

    Mbappe can create goals better, Haaland is the better finisher. I'd pick Haaland tbh, he's got a crazy size power and speed combo I've never seen another player with. Only thing is his longevity. That size might affect him in the years to come.

  • Abdoulie Sagne
    Abdoulie Sagne9 dager siden

    Meanwhile Rashford is still smashing balls straight at keepers. I'm tired.

  • John Flothmann
    John Flothmann9 dager siden

    Why is everyone hyping up these two guys so much? I mean dortmund players always seem to get hyped up as they will probably go to a rich premier league club at some point. But comparing them to messi and ronaldo??? Mbappe will stay at psg forever due to the endless arab money and win only french titles. Id take müller and lewandowski over the haaland and mbappe any day (yes they are 30 but still dont get anywhere near as much hype)

  • Minhaj
    Minhaj9 dager siden

    Here we go again....

  • Josh Meep
    Josh Meep9 dager siden

    The reason Haaland has more goals is because he is the focal point of Dortmunds attack, Mbappe has Neymar and Icardi in the same line up as him, the attack isn't focused on him, imagine of it was

  • N9ne 9999

    N9ne 9999

    8 dager siden

    Mbappe plays in a farmers league so it evens itself out.

  • Anonymous 123
    Anonymous 1239 dager siden

    Atm mbappe bc he’s had more years and he’s a beast however PSG are better than Dortmund and Haaland saves them at times and he’ll only get better

  • L K
    L K9 dager siden

    To be honest Mbappe is already alot more experienced and has had an amazing early career. Haaland has literally just popped up on the scene and is doing bits but nowhere near as experienced or achieved as Mbappe.

  • Nelmab Mayowa
    Nelmab Mayowa9 dager siden

    Mbappe is a more complete and better player with superior skills and pace. Alas! Haaland is just a scary goal scoring machine, a deadly poacher.

  • nema znachenie
    nema znachenie9 dager siden

    I’d have Ronaldo

  • M Mugi
    M Mugi9 dager siden

    Haland might become the highest Goal Scorer of all time if he continues like this for another 15 years.

  • mijuo roui
    mijuo roui9 dager siden

    Haaland's drive is on another level , he is truly one of those guys like Cristiano , Arnold , The rock , who have a tremendous work ethic and want to be the best

  • edouard atangana
    edouard atangana9 dager siden

    mbappe for me

  • bilij pdan
    bilij pdan9 dager siden

    The “farmers” keeps creating quality!

  • Aqua Doze
    Aqua Doze9 dager siden

    On the pitch they may be comparable but on the mic there is only one worth listening to.

  • Aqua Doze

    Aqua Doze

    9 dager siden

    @mijuo roui How many people told Cristiano & Lionel that they would never reach the heights of Pele & Maradona?.. Records are made to be broken.

  • mijuo roui

    mijuo roui

    9 dager siden

    No one can reach the height of cr7 and messi..

  • LogicPak
    LogicPak9 dager siden

    Leeds united will sign Haaland next season.

  • nuvie
    nuvie9 dager siden

    The last striker I saw with those numbers at that age.....Ronaldo R9! Haaland is in good company.

  • bilij pdan

    bilij pdan

    9 dager siden


  • dueeh nyyu
    dueeh nyyu9 dager siden

    of the day they're both amazing

  • Ramadhani Adi
    Ramadhani Adi9 dager siden

    New era is coming?

  • Actually, Movies
    Actually, Movies9 dager siden

    To be honest, I doubt they can ever reach Ronaldo and Messi. Messi and Ronaldo were toying with the defences back at that age

  • Kristjan Rom
    Kristjan Rom9 dager siden

    I just watched Mbappe the other day for the first time and I was seriously impressed

  • dueeh nyyu

    dueeh nyyu

    9 dager siden

    Haaland 🇳🇴

  • Eddy Sakamura
    Eddy Sakamura10 dager siden

    Haaland hat vikinger Mentalität einfach ein geborener Sieger, mbappe brauchte Vorbilder wie Neymar, hat man deutlich gesehen. Blabla mbappe spielt besser.... er ist einfach kleiner deswegen sehen die Bewegungen athletischer aus. Haaland ist mit Abstand besser, er trifft aus unmöglichen lagen unhaltbar das Tor. Haaland spielt als hätte er 40 Jahre fussballerfahrung einfach der beste Spieler weltweit schon jetzt 🤩🤩🤩

  • archipiratta
    archipiratta10 dager siden

    Who goes to Barca and who goes to Real? 🤔🤔

  • deejay sensation
    deejay sensation10 dager siden

    I'm fine with Lord Bendner

  • Marnz
    Marnz10 dager siden

    Mad how neymar was always discussed as no 3 in the world but now don't get recognition as he used to.

  • MimM
    MimM10 dager siden

    Haaland, because Mbappe acts like a Primma Donna already.

  • Thunderworks
    Thunderworks10 dager siden

    Haaland scores two goals against Seville, Mbappé destroys Barça at Camp Nou

  • beedsj roiue
    beedsj roiue10 dager siden

    Lineker said" What are we gonna do when there is no Ronaldo and Messi🤣🤣( pundits will be jobless), so we need something else ( rivalry b/w Haaland and Mbappe) "

  • The AJ
    The AJ10 dager siden

    Erling haland will easily overtake cristano Ronaldo as the highest goal scorer ever in football

  • Shalivahan Patil
    Shalivahan Patil10 dager siden

    No one can reach the height of cr7 and messi..

  • tom.k
    tom.k10 dager siden

    Please don't turn this into the messi ronaldo cult 2.0

  • beedsj roiue

    beedsj roiue

    10 dager siden

    his own do some singlehanded magic where no matter how the team around is playing Haland can give some long strikes when needed or because of his height and legs

  • don juco
    don juco10 dager siden


  • Daniel N Marcello
    Daniel N Marcello10 dager siden

    KMP his natural and he play street football and that's how i see him the best .

  • Omega Level Articuno
    Omega Level Articuno10 dager siden

    Lingardinho 10/10 Times.

  • name
    name10 dager siden

    mbappe learned so much diving from Neymar, good for penalty score

  • Silenti
    Silenti10 dager siden

    Haaland 🇳🇴

  • Espen Liebak
    Espen Liebak10 dager siden

    Haaland any day, he even stand up for his team mates❤️

    RICARDO GONZALEZ10 dager siden

    Neither surprises me their just hype

  • Take me home United road
    Take me home United road10 dager siden

    Mbappe is a beast player but I’d have hala and at man united

  • bssni touir
    bssni touir10 dager siden

    Joe Cole feeling insightful by adding a third "changing of the guard".

  • Andre Brendryen

    Andre Brendryen

    8 dager siden

    bssni touir feeling insightful adding a second "Joe Cole feeling insightful by adding a third "changing of the guard" comment"

  • Hamza Abdirahman
    Hamza Abdirahman10 dager siden

    The thing is messi and Ronaldo played most of there career in wings and they are best players in the world while this guys are strikers so it would be easy for them to take that Rivelary into another lvl.